Lost in the debate of “death panels” and “socialized medicine” is the fact that medical care is not a capitalistic system. There is no demand curve. The Demand-line for health care in a Supply and Demand graph would be straight up. Why? Because, what would you pay to save your life? When would it be too much? (Sorry, Doc, I’m not going to pay a cent over $9,400.) Not only that, but the system isn’t set up for you to even know the prices. How much is it to set a broken bone? Treat a heart attack? Would you take price into consideration even if you knew?
When suppliers can charge whatever they want, then the system isn’t going to work.
Before we begin though there must be some ground rules. No sound bites. No writing off ideas just because there is talk of “death panels” or “socialized medicine”. Sound bites are for the stupid and are not welcome in a serious discussion.
But the first step most people have to do is realize there is a problem. People don’t see the rising costs, but it is breaking us. Local governments are in bankruptcy. Small business can barely hang on now…but what happens when insurance rates go up another 50%? They will. Even the Federal gov’t can’t sustain itself and they are the biggest wallet in the history of man. People also need to realize that they are now paying for those that can’t pay. $95 for an aspirin in the hospital? You are paying for the waiter who doesn’t have health insurance.
The second step is to identify what kind of solution you want. If you want a solution. We can end up with something in the middle but by way of example, here are two extremes:
1. PAY AS YOU GO – You know the prices of everything but you have to pay out of your own pocket. You get to decide if the pain is worth a $5000 trip to the doctor. It would be the ultimate capitalist system. Prices would come down. Innovation would go up. People wouldn’t waste time in ER’s for runny noses. Some would die because they waited too long, but that would have been their choice. Some would die because they can’t afford treatment, but that would be the cost of this solution. The rich would be treated like royalty. Ritz Hospitals would pop up. Individual wealth overall would increase because people aren’t paying insurance. If you are middle class or below, once you have a serious medical issue, you and your family WILL be impoverished. But yeah capitalism! We would instantly eliminate cost overruns because it would only cost what he have.
2. GOVERNMENT HEALTHCARE – Everyone pays in taxes. People don’t die just because they are poor. Innovation is stifled. Quality is less overall but available to everyone. Cost overruns are more likely because bureaucrats are making decisions about spending. No one is bankrupted because of a medical condition.
You have to ask yourself. What do you want to do for those that can’t pay for themselves? Are you willing to let them die? Its fine if you do…just admit it to yourself before we get too far into the discussion. I don’t have a problem with death per se. It’s natural. Your solution is choice #1. Problem solved. For everyone else it might be helpful to figure out where you want to go before we can figure out how to get there.